There is no official top 10 of sustainable cities. Different indexes measure different things, and each one weighs environment, social and economic factors in its own way. Cities in northern Europe appear most often, with a few examples elsewhere, such as Singapore, Vancouver and Curitiba. The useful question is not “which city is number one?” but “what does this list measure, and does that matter for my trip?”
Why there is no single official list
A sustainability ranking is only as good as its method. One index may focus on carbon and transport, another on social wellbeing, and another on how well a city hosts visitors. The same city can rank very differently from one list to the next, and the results change from one edition to the next.
Different indexes measure different things
- Sustainable city indexes cover the whole city: energy, transport, housing, air quality and quality of life.
- Tourism-focused indexes look at how well a destination manages visitors, events and their impact. The Global Destination Sustainability Index (GDS-Index) is one example. Gothenburg ranked first for many years from 2016, but check the latest edition before quoting it.
- European Green Capital is an award for cities that meet environmental standards. Stockholm was the first winner in 2010, and later winners include Copenhagen, Oslo and Vilnius. Check the current list before you use it.
Because the criteria differ, treat any ranking as one opinion among several.
Cities that appear most often, and why
Some cities turn up in almost every list. The reasons vary, but a few themes come up again and again.
Northern Europe: transit, cycling and low-carbon energy
Oslo, Stockholm and Copenhagen appear most often. In the 2022 edition of the Arcadis Sustainable Cities Index, Oslo ranked first, followed by Stockholm, Tokyo and Copenhagen. Oslo’s electric car sales are a large share of new cars sold, and Copenhagen has a high share of commuters who cycle. Copenhagen also announced in 2022 that it would miss its 2025 carbon-neutral target, which is a useful reminder that targets and results can differ.
Helsinki, Amsterdam, Zurich, Vienna and Berlin also appear in many top lists, usually for transit, green space and energy policy.
Elsewhere: Singapore, Vancouver, Curitiba
Singapore calls itself a “City in Nature”, and its Green Plan 2030 sets out its environmental goals. Vancouver’s Greenest City Action Plan ran from 2011 to 2020 and was followed by a Climate Emergency Action Plan. Curitiba, in Brazil, pioneered bus rapid transit in 1974 and is often cited for urban planning. These cities show that high sustainability is not limited to Europe, though each one has its own strengths and gaps.
How to judge a sustainable-city list
Use a few simple checks when you read any list:
- Check the method. Does the list say what it measures, and how the scores were worked out?
- Check the date. Rankings are updated, and older editions may be out of date.
- Check the scope. Does it measure the city itself, or tourism specifically?
- Look for overlap. A city that appears in several independent lists is more likely to be consistent in practice than one that appears in only one.
- Be wary of “zero emissions” claims. No city has reached zero emissions yet, and a rating is a relative judgement, not a guarantee.
Sustainable cities and the flights that get you there
A city can be well run and still be a high-carbon trip if you fly in from far away. For most visitors, the flight is the largest part of the trip’s footprint, and a city’s transit system only helps once you are there. If you want a low-carbon city trip, the mode of travel to the city matters as much as the city itself. Our guide to the most environmentally friendly form of travel compares the options.
Quick checklist for planning a greener city trip
- Choose a city with good public transit, so you can get around without a taxi or rental car.
- Look at the rail link first. A train to the city may beat a flight, depending on the distance.
- Stay in a locally run or independently certified hotel, and check the certification rather than trusting a green label.
- Walk or cycle where you can. Many of the best-rated cities are easy to explore on foot or by bike.
- Check local rules before you go, such as low-emission zones or visitor fees, because they change.
For more on choosing a greener destination, see our pillar guide to ecotourism destinations.