Responsible Travel Habits

Animal Tourism Red Flags: Signs an Attraction Harms Its Animals

Animal tourism red flags: contact experiences, performances, photo props, stress behaviours and cub breeding that signal an attraction may harm its animals.

On this page
  1. Direct contact experiences
  2. Performances and shows
  3. Photo props and selfies
  4. Signs of stress in the animals
  5. Physical signs of mistreatment
  6. Housing and enclosures
  7. Breeding, cubs and “sanctuary” claims
  8. What the research shows
  9. What better signs look like
  10. Common misconceptions
  11. Safety
  12. What to do if you see a red flag

An attraction may be harming its animals if it offers direct contact such as riding or cub petting, puts animals in performances or photo props, or shows signs of stress and poor housing. Breeding young animals with no release plan, and calling a business a “sanctuary” without proof, are also warning signs. Sometimes the signs are visible during a visit. Often they show up in the listing, the reviews or the way the attraction describes itself.

Direct contact experiences

Riding, bathing or hugging elephants, cub petting, walking with lions and holding sloths, slow lorises or snakes are all forms of direct contact. Wild animals are not normally comfortable with that much handling, and the experiences are often stressful even when the animal appears calm. Bathing elephants is still direct contact, and it is increasingly discouraged.

Paying to touch an animal does not fund conservation. Ask where the money goes before you pay.

Performances and shows

Animals doing tricks, wearing costumes, painting, dancing or performing in shows are a clear red flag. Performance training often requires punishment or the removal of natural behaviour, so the act itself can signal a welfare problem.

Photo props and selfies

Wild animals posed for paid selfies are a common form of exploitation. Examples include sloths in the Amazon, slow lorises in Southeast Asia and tigers in Thailand. Sustainable tourism in Thailand covers better alternatives there. Demand for these photos drives capture and handling, and the animals are rarely allowed to behave naturally.

Signs of stress in the animals

Repetitive behaviours can show that an animal is not coping. Watch for:

  • Pacing, swaying or head-bobbing
  • Bar-biting or other repeated movements at fences
  • Self-harm
  • Over-grooming

Calm animals are not necessarily content. Some may be drugged or exhausted, and a lack of visible reaction does not mean the animal is well.

Physical signs of mistreatment

Look for chains, short tethers, bullhooks (hooks used to control elephants), pulled teeth or claws, wounds, and lethargic or drugged animals. These are signs that the animal is being controlled rather than cared for.

Housing and enclosures

Enclosures that are bare concrete, small, or lacking shade, water or hiding places are a red flag. Social animals kept alone, or animals kept in conditions that do not meet their natural needs, are also signs of poor welfare.

Breeding, cubs and “sanctuary” claims

A steady supply of cubs can signal a cub-petting business. Watch for:

  • Breeding young animals with no release programme
  • A “sanctuary” that buys, sells or breeds animals, or allows riding
  • Volunteer programmes that charge to hand-raise cubs or care for orphans, with no release goal

“Sanctuary”, “rescue” and “conservation” are not protected terms in most countries. A rescued animal may still be poorly treated, and a conservation claim may not describe any actual conservation work. That is a form of greenwashing.

What the research shows

Several investigations have looked at wildlife tourism:

  • A 2015 study by World Animal Protection found that about three in four wildlife tourist attractions it reviewed involved animal abuse or conservation concerns.
  • A 2017 World Animal Protection study of around 3,000 tourism elephants in Asia found that about three in four were kept in poor conditions.
  • In 2016, a raid on Thailand’s so-called Tiger Temple reportedly found around 40 dead tiger cubs in a freezer.
  • South Africa has an estimated 8,000 to 12,000 captive lions. In 2021, the government announced it would end captive lion breeding, and that phase-out is ongoing.

These findings are a reason for caution, not proof about any single attraction. Check the specific place you are considering.

What better signs look like

Some signs point to a more responsible attraction:

  • Accreditation from a recognised body, such as the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries (GFAS) for sanctuaries, or the AZA and EAZA for zoos
  • Observation-only rules that visitors and staff follow
  • Visitor limits, so animals are not crowded
  • A clear release or lifelong-care plan for each animal

For more on what to ask before you book, see how to choose an ethical wildlife tour operator.

Common misconceptions

  • Calm animals are content. They may be drugged or exhausted.
  • “Rescued” means well treated. Rescue does not guarantee good conditions.
  • Paying to touch helps conservation. It usually does not, and it often harms the animal.
  • Bathing elephants is harmless enrichment. It is forced contact for many elephants.
  • No riding means an ethical venue. A venue can avoid riding and still use other forms of contact or handling. For elephants, see are elephant sanctuaries ethical?

Safety

Captive big cats and elephants injure and kill visitors and handlers every year. Keep your distance, even from animals that appear tame, and follow the staff’s instructions.

What to do if you see a red flag

  • Don’t pay for the activity, and tell the staff why you are leaving.
  • Choose another attraction that uses observation-only rules.
  • Leave an honest review that describes what you saw.
  • Check whether the attraction holds accreditation before recommending it to others.

Some booking platforms have also stopped selling tickets to certain attractions. TripAdvisor stopped selling tickets to most direct wildlife-contact attractions in 2016, and captive cetacean show tickets in 2019. Platform decisions do not replace your own checks, but they can help you spot the most problematic attractions.

For a broader set of habits, see the responsible ecotourist guide. For how to watch animals without disturbing them, see wildlife viewing etiquette.

The complete guide to responsible travel habits

How to Be a Responsible Ecotourist: Guiding Principles and Eco-Friendly Practices
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →