Carbon offsetting means paying for a project that cuts or removes greenhouse gases, so that you balance out emissions you cause somewhere else. For travel, its main advantage is that it can fund real climate projects now. Its main disadvantages are that it does not cancel the emissions of your trip, the quality of credits varies widely, and it can encourage people to keep emitting without cutting their own emissions.
What a carbon offset is
One carbon credit represents one tonne of CO2 equivalent that has been avoided or removed. To offset a trip, you estimate its emissions with a calculator, buy the matching number of credits and, ideally, the credits are retired so they cannot be sold again. A return economy flight between London and New York is often estimated at around one tonne of CO2e per passenger, though estimates range from roughly 0.6 to 1.7 tonnes depending on the calculator and how non-CO2 effects are counted.
Offsets are typically sold for projects such as wind or solar power, methane capture, forest protection or reforestation, cookstove programmes, and carbon removal technologies.
Advantages of carbon offsetting
- It funds projects now. Money can help build projects that might otherwise lack capital, such as renewable energy or methane capture.
- It can bring co-benefits. Some projects also improve health, protect biodiversity or create local income.
- It puts a price on emissions. A price on carbon can make the cost of emitting visible to travellers and businesses.
- It can be a step for unavoidable travel. When a flight cannot be avoided, offsetting is better than doing nothing, as long as it is treated as a secondary step.
Disadvantages of carbon offsetting
- Moral hazard. Offsetting can be used as a licence to keep emitting without reducing emissions. This is the central greenwashing concern.
- Over-crediting. Projects may be credited for reductions that would have happened anyway, or for more reduction than they actually deliver. Estimates of a project’s impact can be optimistic.
- Impermanence. Carbon stored in a forest or soil can be released by fire, drought, disease or a change in land management.
- Delayed real cuts. Credits do not cut emissions when the flight happens. Projects may take years to deliver their claimed reductions.
- Weak verification. There is no single global standard that guarantees the quality of every offset.
- Low prices. Airline and booking-site offsets often cost a few dollars per flight, which rarely reflects the cost of durable removal.
Disadvantages of carbon farming and forest projects
Carbon farming, including tree planting and changes to soil management, is one of the most common types of offset. Its main risk is permanence. A forest planted today may absorb carbon over decades, but a fire or disease can release that carbon quickly. Soil carbon can be released if the land is managed differently after the project ends.
Projects also face leakage. If a forest is protected in one area, logging may move to another. Buffer zones and monitoring can reduce these risks, but they add cost and are not a complete answer.
Tree planting also has a space limit. Planting enough trees to absorb one year’s global emissions would require far more land than is available, so tree planting cannot solve the problem alone.
Quality tests for credits
Experts generally look at five quality criteria when judging a project:
- Additionality. Would the reduction have happened without the offset money? If a project was already required by law or was already profitable, it fails this test.
- Correct assessment. Emissions reductions should not be overestimated. The baseline, meaning what would have happened otherwise, should be realistic.
- Permanence. Carbon should stay out of the atmosphere for a long time, ideally long enough to match the timeframe used in the calculation.
- Exclusivity. Each credit should be sold once, with the credit retired on sale so no one else can claim it. Double counting is a real risk.
- No harm. The project should not cause other environmental or social damage, such as harming water quality or displacing local residents.
Independent verification helps. Look for projects verified under standards such as Verra, Gold Standard, the Climate Action Reserve or the American Carbon Registry.
Avoidance and removal credits
Avoidance credits pay for projects that stop emissions from happening, such as forest protection or cookstove programmes. They are often cheaper. Removal credits pay for carbon to be taken out of the atmosphere, such as through reforestation, biochar or direct air capture. Removals that store carbon durably are generally seen as more reliable for long-term climate goals, but they are also more expensive. Nature-based credits are often sold for around US$5 to US$20 per tonne, while direct air capture credits can cost several hundred dollars per tonne.
Current standards and rules
Standards for offsets are changing. A few developments are worth knowing:
- The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) published its Core Carbon Principles in 2023 to label higher-integrity credits.
- The Oxford Offsetting Principles (2020) advise cutting emissions first and moving toward removals with durable storage.
- CORSIA, the aviation scheme run by ICAO, has a pilot phase from 2021 to 2023 and a first phase from 2024 to 2026. Participation is expected to become mandatory for most states from 2027.
- EU rules that apply from September 2026 restrict “carbon neutral” product claims that rely on offsets.
A January 2023 investigation by the Guardian, Die Zeit and SourceMaterial found that over 90% of the Verra rainforest credits it studied were unlikely to represent real reductions. Verra disputed the findings, and the case shows why independent checks matter.
Common misconceptions
- Offsets cancel a flight’s emissions. They do not cancel them at the time. They compensate for emissions elsewhere, on a different timescale.
- A certified credit is high quality. Certification is a starting point. The project still has to meet the quality tests.
- Planting trees is the same as permanent removal. Trees can be lost to fire, disease or logging.
- Airline offsets reflect the cost of real removal. They are usually far cheaper than durable removal.
How to use offsets responsibly
- Reduce first. Look for ways to fly less, choose direct flights, or travel overland for shorter trips before you buy offsets.
- Choose specific projects. Vague claims are harder to check than named projects with a public record.
- Check the standard and the verifier. Look for independent verification and a public registry record.
- Ask whether the credits are retired. Retirement helps prevent double counting.
- Be cautious with tree-planting-only schemes. They can be useful for other reasons but are weaker as offsets.
- Look at the whole trip. Make sure the calculation covers the emissions you are responsible for, not just one leg.
Offsets can be one part of a plan. As the limits of sustainable tourism show, they are not a replacement for travelling less. For a look at what that can mean in practice, see flight-free travel. For a recent public example of offset claims, see did Taylor Swift buy carbon offsets?.