Zero-impact tourism is not possible. A sustainable form of tourism, one that keeps impacts within limits and keeps reducing them, is possible. The harder question is whether that is enough, given how fast tourism has grown and how much it emits.
What the numbers show
- Tourism produced about 8 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to a 2018 study by Lenzen and colleagues in Nature Climate Change. That figure includes supply chains.
- Some studies suggest tourism emissions have grown faster than efforts to cut them.
- International arrivals rose from about 25 million in 1950 to about 1.5 billion in 2019.
Growth on that scale makes a managed, measured approach necessary. It also makes single good practices hard to scale on their own.
Flying is the hardest part
Air travel is where most of the difficulty sits.
- Aviation produces about 2.5 per cent of global CO2 emissions. Once non-CO2 effects such as contrails and nitrogen oxides are included, its share of human-caused warming is about 3.5 per cent.
- A return long-haul flight, such as London to New York, emits roughly 0.6 to 1 tonne of CO2e or more per passenger, depending on the method used.
- Sustainable aviation fuel made up about 0.3 per cent of global jet fuel in 2024, according to IATA. Supply remains very small.
- Hydrogen and electric aircraft are unlikely to serve long-haul routes before the 2040s at the earliest. That timeline is uncertain.
- Carbon offsets vary a great deal in quality, and the carbon they store is often not permanent.
For many trips, the largest single decision is whether to fly and how far.
The main criticisms
Greenwashing and ego-tourism
Greenwashing is green marketing that runs ahead of reality. A related criticism, made by writers such as Wheeller in the 1990s, is “ego-tourism”: green travel used as a way to show status rather than to reduce impact.
Rebound effects
Efficiency savings can be spent on more or longer trips. If a flight is cheaper to offset or a hotel uses less water per guest, the saving can simply pay for another trip, cancelling the gain.
Degrowth and its critics
Some argue for degrowth tourism: fewer, longer, closer trips. Critics point out that this could harm economies that depend heavily on tourism, and that the people most affected are often the least able to adapt.
Destination life cycles
Butler’s Tourism Area Life Cycle, set out in 1980, describes destinations moving through stages of exploration, involvement, development, consolidation, then stagnation and decline or rejuvenation. Many popular places are at risk of the later stages, which is one reason for the problems of overtourism.
Stopping tourism is not automatically good
Less tourism does not always mean better outcomes for nature. Lost income can push communities toward other activities that harm wildlife. Reports from some places during the 2020 pandemic linked the collapse of visitor income to more poaching. Sustainable tourism, managed well, can give communities a reason to protect wildlife rather than exploit it.
The continuous-process view
UN Tourism describes sustainability as a continuous process. The point is to improve over time and to measure progress, rather than to reach a pass-or-fail state. That framing is useful, but it can also be used to excuse slow progress, so look for evidence of change.
Where the strongest levers are
The biggest gains tend to come from a small number of decisions:
- Fewer flights and longer stays. Combining them reduces the number of journeys and spreads out their impact.
- More overland travel, by train, bus or boat, where it is practical. See the most environmentally friendly form of travel.
- Local ownership of businesses, so that more of the money stays in the community. Sustainable tourism principles covers this economic point.
- Visitor management, such as caps, timed entry and dispersal.
A realistic standard for travellers
- Accept that you have an impact, and aim to reduce it rather than deny it.
- Prioritise the biggest levers, which are how you travel and how long you stay.
- Ask operators for evidence, not only reassurance.
- Do not assume that a small niche trip solves the impact of mass tourism.
For destinations that try to measure progress against these levers, see sustainable tourism indicators. For how regenerative approaches try to go further, see what is regenerative tourism?