Tourism helps when the money reaches wildlife
Wildlife tourism can help conservation when fees and jobs are real and reach the places where animals live. It can harm wildlife when money stays away from those places, when visitor numbers are not managed, or when animals are handled for the sake of a photo. The rest of this article looks at what separates the two.
How tourism money reaches wildlife
Visitor fees and spending can pay for rangers, anti-poaching patrols, research, monitoring and the upkeep of protected areas. In some places they also pay communities directly, which can make local people more willing to protect wildlife rather than hunt or clear the land it lives on. Visitor photos can also feed citizen-science databases, such as photo-identification projects that track individual animals, including whale sharks.
Mountain gorillas: a conservation case study
Mountain gorillas are one of the best-known examples of tourism supporting conservation. A 2018 count found about 1,063 mountain gorillas, up from roughly 620 in 1989. In 2018, the species was moved from Critically Endangered to Endangered on the IUCN Red List. Tourism-funded protection is one reason for the recovery, though it is not the only one.
Rwanda’s gorilla permit costs US$1,500, and 10% of park revenue is shared with communities around the parks. Trackers check habituated gorilla groups daily, which helps catch snares, injuries and illness early. Visits are tightly limited: groups have at most eight visitors and spend one hour with the family each day.
Marine wildlife: sharks, manta rays and whales
Marine wildlife tourism follows a similar pattern. A 2012 estimate for a reef shark population in Palau put its lifetime dive-tourism value at about US$1.9 million, against about US$108 when the shark was killed (Vianna et al., 2012).
Global estimates are less precise. Shark watching was estimated in 2013 to bring in about US$314 million a year and to involve roughly 590,000 participants worldwide (Cisneros-Montemayor et al., 2013). Manta ray tourism was estimated at about US$140 million a year (O’Malley et al., 2013), though that figure is an estimate. Whale watching in 2008 involved about 13 million people in 119 countries and was worth about US$2.1 billion (O’Connor et al., 2009). These figures are from different years and use different methods, so compare them with care.
Turtles and protected beaches
At Tortuguero in Costa Rica, the number of green turtle nests rose sharply between 1971 and 2003 under protection (Troëng and Rankin, 2005). The case shows that protection can work alongside visitors, but only when access is controlled.
Namibia’s communal conservancies
Namibia has had communal conservancies since 1996, and there are now about 86 of them, covering roughly a fifth of the country. The number changes over time, so check current figures. Conservancies give rural communities rights over wildlife and the income it brings, including from tourism. Several species, including black rhinos, have grown in numbers in conservancy areas. The arrangement works because local people have a stake in keeping wildlife alive.
When wildlife tourism works against wildlife
Not all wildlife tourism helps animals. Some practices cause harm even when they are sold as conservation.
- Handling and riding. Cub petting, elephant rides and “walking with lions” do not contribute to conservation, and some are linked to canned hunting.
- Feeding. Feeding wildlife changes its behavior and can make animals dependent on people. It is also illegal in many parks.
- Crowding and habituation. Too many visitors can stress animals and change their habits. The wildlife habituation article explains why an animal that looks calm may still be affected.
- Disturbance at key sites. Repeated visits to nesting, breeding or feeding areas can reduce survival, as the negative effects of ecotourism article describes.
What makes wildlife tourism help
Across these examples, a few conditions stand out:
- Revenue is shared with local people, and they have a real say in decisions.
- Visitor numbers and group sizes are capped, and the caps are enforced.
- The money is spent on protection, research and monitoring, not only on marketing.
- Rules on distance and feeding are followed, and they are enforced.
- Income is not so dependent on tourism that a single shock, such as COVID-19, leaves the area without protection funding.
Carrying capacity explains how managers set limits like these.
Choosing a trip that helps wildlife
When you are comparing trips, ask:
- How many visitors are in each group, and how often is the site visited?
- Does the operator fund protection or research, and can it show how?
- Who owns the lodge or company, and do local people share in the revenue?
- Are wildlife handled, fed or ridden? If so, skip the trip.
- Does the operator follow a recognized certification or code of conduct?
A trip that meets these tests is more likely to help the animals it is meant to protect.