Ecotourism Pros and Cons

Ecotourism Displacement: When Protected Areas Push Out Local People

When parks and tourism take land, local people can lose homes, grazing and fishing access. Learn the main cases, the rights debate and what to check.

On this page
  1. Displacement has happened, and its scale is disputed
  2. What displacement means
  3. Historical roots
  4. Recent cases
  5. How many people are affected?
  6. How ecotourism can add pressure
  7. Rights frameworks and better models
  8. What to check before you book

Displacement has happened, and its scale is disputed

Protected areas and tourism developments have displaced local people in many places. In some cases people were moved by force, and in others they were stopped from using land they had relied on for generations. Whether ecotourism itself is to blame varies from case to case, and the total number of people affected is hard to measure.

What displacement means

Displacement can be physical or economic. Physical displacement is when people are moved from their homes or land. Economic displacement is when people lose access to grazing, fishing or forest resources without being moved at all. Both can happen when land is set aside for conservation or tourism.

Researchers have a name for the pattern: “green grabbing” is a term used by Fairhead and colleagues (2012) for land or sea taken for conservation or tourism in ways that benefit outsiders more than the people who lived there.

Historical roots

Yellowstone was established as a national park in 1872, and the creation of the park was followed by the exclusion of Native peoples, including the Shoshone, Bannock and Crow, from land they had used. Yellowstone is often cited as an early example of “fortress conservation,” the model of keeping people out of protected land. In the Serengeti, the Maasai were moved out in 1959 to the Ngorongoro Conservation Area, which was set up as a multiple-use area.

Recent cases

  • Ngorongoro, Tanzania. Since 2022, the government has relocated people to Msomera in Handeni district. The government describes the moves as voluntary. Rights groups dispute this, and the relocations are linked to conservation and tourism goals. Both positions should be considered when reading about the case.
  • Loliondo, Tanzania. In June 2022, about 1,500 km² was marked off as a game-controlled area. Clashes were reported, and some people fled to Kenya.
  • Bwindi and Mgahinga, Uganda. The Batwa were evicted when these forests became national parks in 1991. Many remain landless.
  • Central Kalahari Game Reserve, Botswana. San residents were removed in 1997 and 2002. The High Court ruled the removals unlawful in 2006, but access to the reserve is still restricted.

How many people are affected?

Estimates of how many people have been displaced by protected areas vary widely, and many are disputed. The term “conservation refugees,” popularized by journalist Mark Dowie in 2009, is a useful way to describe the problem, but it does not come with a reliable headline number. Be wary of any single figure that claims to cover the whole world.

How ecotourism can add pressure

Tourism can add to displacement pressure in several specific ways:

  • Lodges and tourism developments can take land that residents used for grazing, farming or settlement.
  • Leases and concessions can move control of land and water to outside companies.
  • Rising land and food prices can push residents out of areas where they have lived for generations.
  • Revenue can flow to outside operators, so people who lose access may not share the benefits.

Rights frameworks and better models

International standards now put more weight on consent and rights. Article 10 of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007) says Indigenous peoples must not be removed from their lands without their free, prior and informed consent and fair compensation. The IUCN World Parks Congress in Durban (2003) moved conservation policy toward a rights-based approach. The Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework (2022) sets a target to protect 30% of land and sea by 2030 while respecting Indigenous and traditional territories. Indigenous peoples manage or hold tenure over at least about a quarter of the world’s land (Garnett et al., 2018).

Other models exist. Namibia’s communal conservancies, set up in 1996, give communities rights over wildlife and the income it brings. Co-management shares decisions between governments and local people. Indigenous and community conserved areas (ICCAs) are managed by the people who live in them. Australia has created Indigenous Protected Areas since 1997.

What to check before you book

Before booking a lodge or tour near a park, ask:

  • Who owns the lodge or company, and who owns the land it sits on?
  • Are local people paid, and do they have a say in how the land is used?
  • Was the site created by moving people off it? If so, were they consulted and compensated?
  • Are guides and other staff from the local community, and in which roles?
  • Is there a written agreement with the community, and can you read it?

A lodge being local does not mean it is locally owned. Check the ownership and the land rights.

For a balanced view of the trade-offs, see our pros and cons of ecotourism guide. For how the benefits of tourism are shared, see the benefits of eco-tourism, and for broader harms, see the negative effects of ecotourism.

The complete guide to ecotourism pros and cons

Ecotourism Pros and Cons: Impacts, Issues and Challenges
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →